Managed Payroll · Choosing a Provider

The one question about a payroll service provider most buyers never ask.

Every payroll service provider says it handles your taxes and filings. Whether it can actually sign and file certain returns on your behalf, versus just preparing them for you to sign, is a real, checkable distinction the IRS defines, and it is worth knowing before you sign a contract.

See your exact monthly & annual price - no call required

See pricing before you talk to anyone. No demo gate, no obligation, and no co-employment.

from $45PEPM, your platform or ours
Not a PEOYou stay the employer of record
3-5 DaysTo live managed payroll

Bottom Line Up Front

A payroll service provider prepares your paychecks, payroll tax deposits, and federal filings. Not every provider can actually sign and electronically file those returns for you; that authority belongs to a specific IRS-recognized category called a reporting agent. BEG runs the full function, your platform or ours, from $45 PEPM.

A Real Checkable Distinction

Payroll service provider vs. reporting agent: what's the actual difference?

A reporting agent is a type of payroll service provider authorized on IRS Form 8655 to sign and electronically file certain employment tax returns on the employer's behalf. A standard provider prepares those returns, but the employer still signs them.

The IRS describes both roles under its third-party payer arrangements framework: both a payroll service provider and a reporting agent can prepare paychecks, prepare and file Forms 940 and 941, make federal tax deposits, and handle W-2s and W-3s. The difference is authorization and signing. A reporting agent uses Form 8655 rather than a general service agreement, and can sign and e-file certain returns for the employer. A provider that is not an authorized reporting agent prepares the same forms, but the employer is still the one who signs them. Most buyers never ask which category they are hiring, and most sales conversations never bring it up.

This is not a reason to distrust a provider that is not a reporting agent. It is a reason to know, going in, exactly who is signing your returns, since that is the kind of detail that only surfaces after a filing problem if you do not ask first.

What To Actually Check

Four questions to ask any payroll service provider before signing

Who signs the returns?

Ask directly whether the provider is an IRS-authorized reporting agent (Form 8655) or whether you are still the one signing every filing.

What happens when a notice arrives?

A tax notice after a filing is normal. Ask who responds to it, how fast, and whether that is included or billed separately.

Is there a real point of contact?

A named person who answers, not a rotating support queue, is what actually reduces your exposure as the employer.

Does it require migrating platforms?

Some providers only work if you move onto their own software. Confirm whether the provider can operate inside the platform you already use.

Is the fee all-in or stacked with add-ons?

Base price plus per-filing fees, per-W-2 fees, and support fees can roughly double the advertised rate. Ask for one number before you sign.

Comparing providers side by side? See how to evaluate payroll companies. Want the full employer-liability picture first? Read what an employer payroll provider actually takes off your desk. For the full scope of what BEG runs, start at managed payroll services.

Not a PEO

You stay the employer of record, every time.

BEG processes payroll on your behalf. It never becomes a co-employer, and your legal relationship with your workforce never changes.

See Your Number First

Get your exact monthly rate before you talk to anyone.

Answer a few questions about headcount and states, and see your exact monthly cost on screen. No sales call required to get the number.

90 seconds. Your exact monthly and annual rate, on screen.

FAQ

Payroll service provider, common questions

What does a payroll service provider actually do?

A payroll service provider handles payroll and employment tax tasks on an employer's behalf: preparing paychecks, preparing and filing Forms 940 and 941, making federal tax deposits, and handling W-2s and W-3s, per the IRS third-party payer framework.

What is the difference between a payroll service provider and a reporting agent?

A reporting agent is a specific type of payroll service provider authorized on IRS Form 8655 to sign and electronically file certain returns on the employer's behalf. A standard payroll service provider prepares those returns for the employer to sign; it does not have that signing authority unless it is also an authorized reporting agent.

Should I check whether my payroll provider is an IRS-authorized reporting agent?

If you want your provider able to electronically sign and file returns like Forms 940 and 941 on your behalf, yes. If a provider only prepares the forms for you to sign yourself, that is a meaningfully different scope of service, and it is worth confirming which one you are actually buying.

Is BEG a payroll service provider or a PEO?

BEG is a payroll service provider, not a PEO. You remain the sole employer of record; BEG never becomes a co-employer, and there is no change to your legal relationship with your workforce.

How fast can I switch payroll service providers?

BEG typically brings a new employer live in 3-5 business days, inside your existing payroll platform, with no requirement to migrate first.

Ready?

See your price before you talk to anyone.

Answer a few questions, get your exact number in about 90 seconds. No call required, no commitment.

See your exact monthly & annual price - no call required