Managed Payroll · PEO Alternative

A PEO takes payroll off your desk by becoming a co-employer of your own staff. There is a way to get the first part without the second.

Companies leave PEOs for three reasons: the bundled invoice hides what anything actually costs, the contract is rigid, and co-employment means a third party is legally treated as the employer of your people. Managed payroll solves the administrative burden without any of that. You stay the sole employer of record. This page covers what co-employment actually means under federal tax law, what it really takes to exit a PEO mid-year, and what the alternative costs in plain numbers.

See your exact monthly & annual price - no call required

Business owner reviewing a PEO invoice and comparing managed payroll alternatives

ZeroCo-employment, you stay sole employer

$25-$45PEPM, all-inclusive, no bundling

3-5 DaysFrom signing to live payroll

TL;DR

The main alternatives to a PEO are an ASO, a managed payroll service, or payroll software you run yourself. Managed payroll is the closest match if what you actually wanted was the work handled, not a co-employer. BEG runs the full payroll function at $25 to $45 per employee per month with a $500 monthly minimum, you remain the sole employer of record, and there is no bundled benefits markup inside the invoice. The hardest part of leaving a PEO is not the notice letter, it is the tax and benefits sequencing, which is covered in detail below.

The Part Most Guides Skip

What does co-employment actually mean in a PEO arrangement?

Co-employment is not a marketing term. It is a specific federal tax treatment with real consequences for who is liable, who files, and who controls the relationship.

A certified PEO is treated as the employer for federal employment tax purposes

Under Internal Revenue Code section 3511, a certified professional employer organization is treated as the employer of a worksite employee for wages it pays, and no other entity is treated as the employer for those wages. The IRS explains the arrangement and its limits on its own page for certified professional employer organizations. That is the legal substance behind the phrase co-employment.

The CPEO, not you, is generally liable for the employment taxes it reports

For remuneration a CPEO pays to worksite employees, the CPEO is generally solely liable for the employment taxes, the returns, and the deposits. For non-worksite employees, the IRS notes the CPEO and its customer may both be liable. The IRS guidance for CPEO customers spells out what transfers and what does not, and it is worth reading before you assume your exposure is zero.

Not every PEO is certified, and the difference matters

CPEO certification is voluntary. The IRS maintains a public list of certified organizations and describes the broader category of third party payer arrangements separately. With a non-certified PEO the liability protection above does not automatically apply, which means an unpaid deposit can still come back to you.

You give up some control over your own employment decisions

Co-employment means a second entity holds employer status over your staff for defined purposes. In practice that shows up as constraints on handbook language, benefit plan selection, termination process, and how quickly you can change a policy. Some companies accept this trade. Others discover it only after signing.

The Three Complaints

Why do companies look for a PEO alternative?

Almost every exit conversation reduces to one of these three. None of them is about whether the PEO does the work competently.

Opacity

You cannot see what any single thing costs

A PEO invoice bundles the administrative fee, health premiums, workers compensation, and payroll taxes into one number, often quoted as a percentage of payroll. That structure makes it nearly impossible to tell whether you are getting a good benefits rate and a bad admin rate, or the reverse. It also means your cost rises automatically every time you give a raise.

Rigidity

All of it or none of it, on their renewal calendar

PEO agreements are typically packaged and annual. If you only needed payroll and compliance handled, you are still buying the benefits platform, the HR advisory layer, and the workers compensation program. Companies that grow past the package, or that never needed all of it, end up paying for capacity they do not use.

Control

Someone else is on the employment relationship

This is the one that surfaces late. Founders and CFOs are usually comfortable outsourcing the work and much less comfortable discovering that a third party holds employer status over their team, appears on employee tax documents, and has a say in employment policy. Managed payroll does not create that relationship at all.

The Real Option Set

What are the alternatives to a PEO?

Four models, and they differ on exactly two axes that matter: who does the work, and who is the employer.

Model	Who does the payroll work	Who is the employer	Best fit when
PEO	The PEO	Co-employer with you	You want pooled benefits and will accept co-employment and bundled pricing to get them
ASO or HRO	The provider, unbundled	You, solely	You want administration handled but need to keep your own benefit plans and carrier relationships
Managed payroll (BEG)	BEG, end to end	You, solely	Payroll and compliance are the actual burden and you want them gone at a flat, visible rate
Payroll software	You and your team	You, solely	You have someone internally whose job can genuinely absorb payroll, compliance, and year end

The honest version: if the reason you joined a PEO was access to large group health rates, an alternative will not replicate that on day one and you should weigh it carefully. If the reason you joined was that nobody internally wanted to own payroll, you bought a co-employment relationship to solve a staffing problem, and fully managed payroll solves that directly for a fraction of the cost of the $60,000 to $100,000 internal hire the PEO was standing in for.

What Nobody Puts On The Page

What actually happens when you leave a PEO mid-year?

This is the part that sits behind a gated download on most competing pages. It is also the part that decides whether your exit is clean or expensive, so here it is in full.

Your federal unemployment wage base can restart

FUTA is owed on the first $7,000 of each employee wages for the year, as the IRS sets out in Topic 759 on Form 940. When employer status changes mid-year, whether the wages already paid count toward that base depends on whether the successor employer rules apply to your situation. Get this answered in writing before you pick an exit date, because the wrong answer means paying the same wage base twice in one calendar year across your whole headcount.

The same question applies at the state level, per state

State unemployment tax has its own wage base and its own successor employer rules, and they are not uniform. A company operating in six states is answering this question six times. The general federal deposit and reporting framework is in IRS Publication 15, but the state answers come from each state agency.

You may need to open or reactivate state tax accounts

While in a PEO, filings often ran under the PEO account numbers rather than yours. Coming out, you need active withholding and unemployment accounts in every state where you have employees, with rates assigned. Agencies do not turn these around instantly. This is the single most common cause of a delayed PEO exit.

Benefits and workers compensation do not travel with you

Health coverage inside a PEO usually sits on the PEO master plan. Leaving means sourcing your own plan with its own effective date, and a gap between the two is a real risk to your employees, not a paperwork issue. Workers compensation is the same story: the PEO policy covered you as a co-employed workforce, and you will need your own policy in force on day one.

Year-to-date data has to land somewhere accurate

Wages, taxes withheld, deductions, and employer contributions all have to carry forward correctly or January W-2s are wrong. Confirm in writing who issues the W-2 for the portion of the year spent inside the PEO and who issues it for the portion after. Ambiguity here is discovered at year end, which is the worst possible time.

Then, and only then, give notice

Notice goes out after the destination is confirmed, the state accounts are moving, and the benefits effective date is locked. Companies that give notice first end up negotiating from a position where the clock is running and nothing is ready.

Quarter boundaries make steps one, two, and five substantially simpler, and January 1 makes them simplest of all. The general sequencing for any provider change is covered in how to switch payroll providers. A PEO exit is that process plus the employer status change, which is why it needs more lead time than a straight provider swap.

Transparent Pricing

What does the alternative cost?

One number, published, not quoted as a percentage of your payroll.

$25 PEPM

Inside the payroll platform you already have

If you are coming out of a PEO into a platform you already own, or one you are selecting now, BEG operates inside it. Processing, tax filings, W-2s, garnishments, new hire reporting, compliance monitoring, and year end close are all included in the number.

$45 PEPM

On the BEG isolved platform, all-inclusive

If you are leaving a PEO and have no platform of your own, this is the clean landing spot: the system and the managed service in one rate, with employee self-service included. No implementation fee.

A $500 monthly minimum applies, which binds below roughly 20 employees at the $25 rate. At 50 employees the range is $1,250 to $2,250 per month, all in, and it does not move when you give raises because it is priced per employee rather than as a percentage of payroll. Compare that against your current PEO invoice line by line with the free payroll fee auditor before you talk to anyone, including us. Full detail is on managed payroll pricing.

Evaluation Criteria

What to check in any PEO alternative

Use this as your question list for every provider you talk to, this one included.

Does anyone become a co-employer, ever
Is the rate per employee or a percentage of payroll
Are tax filings and W-2s in the base rate or extra
Who handles multi-state registration and rates
Is there an implementation fee
Who answers an employee paycheck question

What happens to garnishments and court orders
Is a parallel cycle run before go live
Who owns the data and how do you get it back
What is the notice period and renewal date
Who files the final returns for the PEO period
How fast is go live, in business days

For multi-state teams coming out of a PEO, the registration question is the one that sets your timeline. See multi-state managed payroll.

The BEG Answer

Three reasons managed payroll replaces a PEO cleanly

Reason 01

You stay the sole employer of record

BEG is a service provider, not a co-employer. Your EIN stays on the returns, your name stays on the W-2s, and every employment decision stays yours. Nothing about your legal relationship with your own staff changes.

Reason 02

The invoice is one line you can read

Headcount times a published rate. No percentage of payroll, no benefits markup buried inside an admin fee, no separate charge appearing in January for W-2s. You can forecast it a year out on a napkin.

Reason 03

The work genuinely leaves your desk

This is where software alternatives fail. BEG runs the cycles, files the taxes, handles garnishments, monitors compliance, closes the year, and answers employee paycheck questions. Delivered remotely, nationwide, in all 50 states.

The Belief Behind This Page

Payroll and HR busywork is a tax on growth. It produces no revenue, it compounds with headcount, and it punishes you asymmetrically when it goes wrong. A PEO recognizes that and charges you for co-employment to fix it. Managed payroll recognizes it and just does the work. For a fraction of what a $60,000 to $100,000 internal hire costs, the function becomes invisible and handled.

Before You Commit To An Exit Date

Find your PEO notice period and renewal date, and get the wage base question answered for every state you operate in. Those two answers set your timeline. On our side live payroll runs 3 to 5 business days from signing, so we are almost never the constraint.

FAQ

Common questions about PEO alternatives

What is the best alternative to a PEO?

It depends on why you joined one. If you wanted pooled health rates, an ASO paired with your own broker is the closest match. If you wanted the payroll work handled without a co-employer, managed payroll is the direct replacement, and it costs less because you are not buying a benefits platform alongside it.

Is managed payroll the same as a PEO?

No. A PEO becomes a co-employer of your staff and is treated as the employer for the wages it pays. A managed payroll provider is a service vendor. You remain the sole employer of record, your EIN stays on the filings, and no third party gains employer status over your people.

Can I leave a PEO in the middle of the year?

Yes, but sequence it deliberately. The two items that decide whether a mid-year exit is expensive are whether your federal and state unemployment wage bases restart, and whether your own state tax accounts are active before the first run. Quarter end is materially cleaner, and January 1 is cleanest.

Will my employees lose their benefits if we leave the PEO?

Not if the new coverage is effective the day the old coverage ends. Health plans inside a PEO usually sit on the PEO master plan and do not transfer, so you need your own plan and your own workers compensation policy in force on day one. Line up the effective dates before you give notice.

How much does a PEO alternative cost compared to a PEO?

BEG managed payroll is $25 per employee per month inside your existing platform or $45 on BEG isolved, all-inclusive, with a $500 monthly minimum. PEOs typically price as a percentage of payroll or a bundled per-employee rate that includes benefits and workers compensation, so compare the administrative portion specifically rather than the invoice totals.

Who issues the W-2 for the part of the year we were in a PEO?

Confirm this in writing during the exit, not at year end. Generally the certified PEO reports the wages it paid and you report the wages you pay after the transition, which can mean employees receive two forms for one year. Employees should be told this in advance so it is not a surprise in January.

How quickly can BEG take over payroll after a PEO exit?

Live payroll typically runs 3 to 5 business days from signing, including a parallel cycle, with no implementation fee. The longer pole is almost always the state tax account registrations and the benefits effective date, which is why those start first.